Guide: Assessment of Eva Madison
A guide for nursing and social work students on the Eva Madison case study, from biopsychosocial assessment to intervention planning.
SiteJabber: 4.9/5
Trustpilot: 3.8/5
Calculate Your Price
Deconstructing the Eva Madison Case
The Assessment of Eva Madison is a common case study for nursing and social work students. It centers on an 80-year-old widow living alone who is presenting a complex mix of social isolation, safety risks, and potential cognitive decline or depression after a recent fall.
When you first read the case notes on Eva Madison, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. Where do you start? She’s refusing help, her son David is worried, she’s leaving the stove on, and she seems depressed. This guide provides a structured framework to complete your assessment. We will use the biopsychosocial model to organize the facts and build an intervention plan—the same process our top academic experts use for a case study analysis.
The ‘Macro Context’: A Biopsychosocial Framework
Your analysis must be holistic. The “macro context” isn’t just one problem (like the fall); it’s the combination of three core areas. As a 2024 update on geriatric assessment confirms, this multi-domain approach is essential in primary care to identify and manage complex health issues in older adults.
1. Biological Factors
These are the physical facts of the case.
• Age: 80 years old, which carries higher risk for falls and co-morbidities.
• Health: Recent fall, potential for injury.
• Safety: Is she malnourished? Are her memory lapses (e.g., stove) from a reversible cause like a UTI or medication side effects, or something progressive?
2. Psychological Factors
This is the core ambiguity of the case.
• Mood: She presents with apathy, tearfulness, and statements like “I don’t know,” which strongly suggest depression.
• Cognition: She also shows memory lapses and confusion. Your key task is to discuss the differential diagnosis of depression vs. dementia. As 2024 guidance on later-life depression and dementia notes, the two are deeply linked, and one can worsen the other.
3. Social Factors
Eva’s environment is a critical factor.
• Support System: She is a widow and lives alone. Her only support is her son, David.
• Isolation: She is socially isolated, a major risk factor for both depression and cognitive decline.
• Caregiver Burden: David is overwhelmed. 2025 research on caregiver well-being shows that supporting the caregiver is essential for the patient’s well-being.
The ‘Contextual Border’: Autonomy vs. Safety
This is the central ethical dilemma in Eva’s case. It’s the “contextual border” that complicates your recommendations. You must balance two competing ethical principles in your ethics paper or assessment.
Eva’s Right to Autonomy
Eva is an adult with the right to make her own decisions, even if her son (or you) thinks they are poor ones. She is refusing help.
Your assessment must respect this. You cannot force interventions unless she is formally deemed to lack the decisional capacity to understand the risks of her choices. This is a critical legal and ethical line you must discuss.
The Duty of Beneficence (Safety)
As a nurse or social worker, you have a professional duty to act in the client’s best interest and protect them from harm (beneficence).
Leaving the stove on is a clear, immediate safety risk to herself and her neighbors. Her malnutrition and isolation are also forms of harm. Your report must weigh these risks against her autonomy and propose the *least restrictive* interventions first.
The ‘Micro Context’: Your Assessment & Intervention Plan
This is the “how-to” for your assignment. Here is a step-by-step plan to structure your case study solution.
Step 1: Recommend Specific Tools
Your *first* recommendation should be for further, formal assessment. Name specific, standardized tools:
• Cognition: Mini-Mental State Exam (MMSE) or Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA).
• Depression: Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS).
• Function (Basic): Katz Index of ADLs.
• Function (Complex): Lawton Scale of IADLs (Instrumental Activities of Daily Living).
Step 2: Create a Problem List
List the problems by priority, from most to least urgent.
1. High-Risk Safety: Risk of fire (stove), risk of falls, potential malnutrition.
2. Psychological: Suspected depression and/or cognitive impairment.
3. Social: Social isolation, caregiver (David) burnout, lack of supervision.
4. Functional: Difficulty with IADLs (cooking, managing home).
Step 3: Propose Interventions
Match interventions to problems.
• Safety: Home safety evaluation (e.g., install smoke detectors, remove rugs), ‘Meals on Wheels,’ medication review.
• Psych/Social: Refer for neurological/psychiatric eval to rule out depression. Arrange transport to a senior day program to combat isolation.
• Family: Connect David with a caregiver support group.
Step 4: Emphasize the MDT
No one person can solve this. Your plan must involve a Multidisciplinary Team (MDT).
This includes her Primary Care Physician (PCP) to rule out medical causes (like a UTI), a social worker (for resources), a home health nurse (for safety checks), and possibly a neurologist for a dementia workup.
Step 5: Discuss the Ambiguity
A top-grade paper doesn’t “solve” the case with a neat bow. It discusses the ambiguity.
State clearly that you cannot definitively diagnose dementia vs. depression without further assessment. Your plan is *how to get* that diagnosis while managing her immediate safety risk. This shows critical thinking.
Step 6: Get a Model Solution
Stuck on how to phrase your assessment? The easiest way to learn is from a professional example.
Our nursing and psychology writers can complete a custom model paper based on the Eva Madison case, giving you a perfect template to follow.
Meet Your Nursing & Social Work Experts
Our team includes advanced-degree specialists in gerontology, psychology, and nursing to handle complex case studies like Eva Madison’s.
Stephen Kanyi, MSc (Biology)
Healthcare & Nursing Specialist
Stephen is our expert for the biological assessment. He can analyze the medical side of Eva’s case, such as fall risks, medication side effects, and the clinical signs of dementia.
Julia Muthoni, MA (Psychology)
Psychology & Counseling Specialist
Julia is our specialist for the psychological component. She excels at analyzing the depression vs. dementia ambiguity, applying tools like the GDS, and discussing patient autonomy.
Simon Njeri, MA (Econ & Sociology)
Social Work & Policy Specialist
Simon handles the social factors of the case. He’s an expert in community resources, social isolation, caregiver burden, and the ethical issues in social work.
Eric Tatua, BSc
Research & Case Study Specialist
Eric is an expert at structuring complex assignments. He can take all the elements of Eva’s case and build a perfectly formatted, well-argued case study solution for you.
Student Feedback
“The team at Custom University Papers delivered an exceptional research paper ahead of schedule. The quality was outstanding, and their attention to detail truly impressed me. Highly recommend for anyone needing reliable academic support!”
– A. Johnson, University of London
“I was struggling with a complex engineering assignment, and their professional guidance was a game-changer. They helped me understand the concepts and improve my problem-solving skills. My grades have significantly improved since using their service.”
– M. Patel, Imperial College London
“Their customer support is incredibly responsive and helpful. I’ve. I’ve used their services for several essays, and each time the work has been original, well-researched, and delivered promptly. A truly reliable partner for academic success.”
– S. Chen, University of Toronto
Common Questions on the Eva Madison Case
Q: Who is Eva Madison in the case study?
A: Eva Madison is the subject of a common nursing and social work case study. She is an 80-year-old widow who lives alone and is experiencing challenges after a recent fall. The case requires students to assess her for cognitive decline (like dementia), depression, social isolation, and safety risks (like malnutrition or leaving the stove on).
Q: What is a biopsychosocial assessment?
A: A biopsychosocial assessment is a holistic framework used in healthcare to understand a client’s health. It examines three interconnected areas: 1) Biological factors (physical health, medications, age), 2) Psychological factors (mood, cognition, mental health), and 3) Social factors (living situation, family support, finances, community).
Q: What are ADLs and IADLs in this case?
A: ADLs (Activities of Daily Living) are basic self-care tasks like dressing, eating, bathing, and toileting. IADLs (Instrumental Activities of Daily Living) are more complex tasks needed for independent living, such as managing finances, cooking, shopping, and taking medications. Eva may be struggling with IADLs (e.g., cooking safety), which is a key part of the assessment.
Q: How do you differentiate depression from dementia here?
A: It is difficult without a full workup. However, depression in seniors (sometimes called ‘pseudodementia’) can mimic dementia. Key differences to look for: Depression-related cognitive issues often have a more rapid onset, and the patient may answer “I don’t know” frequently. Dementia-related decline is typically gradual, and the patient may try to hide their memory deficits (confabulate). The Eva Madison case requires recommending further assessment (e.g., GDS for depression, MMSE for cognition) to find the root cause.
Q: How can I get help with my Eva Madison case study?
A: Our service provides custom-written model answers for case studies like Eva Madison’s. Our nursing and psychology experts can complete a full analysis, including a biopsychosocial assessment, application of assessment tools, and a detailed intervention plan. You can use this model as a perfect guide to structure your own paper.
Master Your Geriatric Assessment
Analyzing the Eva Madison case requires a blend of clinical knowledge, psychological insight, and social work ethics. It’s a complex task of balancing safety with autonomy. When you need a model paper to guide your analysis, our team is here to support you.
