Dragons in Legend: From Fáfnir to Smaug
A Study of the Northern Dragon Archetype.
An analysis of the mythological line from the dragons of Beowulf and the Volsunga Saga to Tolkien’s Smaug.
Order Comparative EssayAn Ancient Malice
My childhood image of a dragon was Smaug the Golden: a vast, intelligent terror on a pile of treasure. A university mythology course introduced me to his ancestors: the bane of Beowulf and the dwarf-turned-dragon, Fáfnir. Smaug was not a new creation but the culmination of a literary tradition.
This guide traces that literary DNA. J.R.R. Tolkien, a scholar of Old English and Norse literature, knew these ancient dragons intimately. Smaug is a masterclass in adaptation, taking the Germanic dragon archetype and elevating it into a true character. Understanding this lineage is key to any analysis of The Hobbit and the broader mythology of Middle-earth.
The Germanic Dragon Archetype
The dragons of Northern European myth are distinct. They are not the benevolent dragons of East Asia. The Germanic dragon (*draca*) is a monster embodying greed, death, and the ancient world. Its core attributes are:
- A Serpent Form: They are serpentine, winged, and fire-breathing, often called “wyrms.”
- Hoard-Guarding: They guard a vast, cursed treasure hoard in a barrow or mountain.
- Ancient Malevolence: They are ancient beings representing a primal force of destruction.
Case Study 1: The Dragon in Beowulf
In the final act of the epic, an aged Beowulf faces a dragon awakened when a slave steals a goblet from its hoard. Enraged, the dragon burns the surrounding lands. Beowulf confronts the dragon, and though he slays it, he is mortally wounded. The dragon in Beowulf is a symbol of greed and the inevitability of death, a fitting end for a hero in a world defined by the struggle against mortality.
Case Study 2: Fáfnir from the Volsunga Saga
The Icelandic Volsunga Saga presents Fáfnir, a dwarf who murdered his father for a cursed treasure. His greed transformed him into a dragon to guard his gold. The hero Sigurd digs a pit and stabs the dragon from beneath. By tasting the dragon’s heart, Sigurd gains the ability to understand birds. Fáfnir represents the corrupting power of greed. This story is central to dragon lore analysis in academic works like those on Norse literature.
Tolkien’s Synthesis: Smaug
In Smaug, Tolkien combines the fury of the Beowulf dragon with the malice of Fáfnir, then adds personality. Smaug is not just a symbol; he is a character—intelligent, vain, and cunning. His conversation with Bilbo is a memorable scene in The Hobbit. He embodies the archetype but also transcends it, a fully realized individual whose arrogance is his downfall.
Key Thematic Parallels
The Hoard and “Dragon-Sickness”
In all three stories, the treasure is central. It is a source of corruption known as “dragon-sickness,” breeding greed in all who desire it, including the dragon and those who seek the hoard, like Thorin Oakenshield.
The Single Theft
Tolkien borrows a plot device from Beowulf. The dragon’s rage is awakened by the theft of a single item—a cup. This emphasizes the dragon’s obsessive possessiveness.
The Weak Point
Each dragon has a vulnerable spot on its underside. This detail highlights that even the greatest evil has a weakness that can be exploited by the small or observant.
The Hero’s Role: Slayer vs. Burglar
Beowulf the King
Beowulf fights the dragon out of duty. As king, it is his responsibility to protect his people. His motive is selfless, and he dies a hero’s death fulfilling his role.
Sigurd the Hero
Sigurd kills Fáfnir as a heroic deed to win fame and treasure. His motive is personal glory, fitting the hero archetype of the saga tradition.
Bilbo the Burglar
Tolkien subverts this. Bilbo is not a hero-slayer. His role is to be a stealthy burglar. He confronts the dragon with wit, not weapons, and his greatest victory is discovering the weak spot, not dealing the final blow.
The Aftermath: Cursed Gold and Moral Decay
What happens after the dragon dies is as important as the battle itself. The cursed hoard continues to cause ruin, testing the morality of the victors.
- In Beowulf, the treasure is re-buried with the fallen king, declared useless to men. The story ends on a note of loss and futility.
- In the Volsunga Saga, the cursed hoard, including the ring Andvaranaut, passes to Sigurd and his family, leading to a chain of betrayal, murder, and tragedy.
- In The Hobbit, the “dragon-sickness” infects Thorin, turning him paranoid and greedy. His refusal to share the treasure nearly causes a war, showing that the dragon’s moral poison lingers even after its death.
Our Literature & Mythology Experts
Our writers can help you craft a nuanced analysis of Tolkien’s literary influences.
Zacchaeus Kiragu
Literature & History
With expertise in comparative literature and Old English, Zacchaeus can guide students through an analysis of Smaug and his mythological predecessors.
Julia Muthoni
Communication & Narrative Structure
Julia excels at analyzing character archetypes and can help you deconstruct how Tolkien evolved the dragon from a monster into a character.
Student Feedback
“I had to write a comparative essay on Smaug and the Beowulf dragon. This guide was the perfect starting point, and my writer helped me find great sources.”
– Maria G., Literature Student
“The connection to Fáfnir and the corrupting power of greed became the central theme of my paper. The expert I worked with helped me explore this in detail.”
– Alex P., Mythology Major
“Understanding that Tolkien gave Smaug a personality was a key insight. It changed my whole approach to the character.”
– Kevin T., Humanities Student
Dragon Lore FAQs
Why are these dragons so obsessed with gold?
In Germanic myth, gold represents earthly power. The dragon’s hoarding is a symbol of all-consuming greed. The dragon cannot use the gold, only possess it, making it the ultimate symbol of avarice.
Are there other dragons in Tolkien’s work?
Yes. Smaug is one of the last great dragons. The first and greatest was Glaurung, the Father of Dragons, who is a central figure in the tragic story of Túrin Turambar in The Silmarillion.
Did the dragons in the original myths talk?
Yes. Fáfnir in the Volsunga Saga speaks to Sigurd. This ability is a key attribute of the archetype. Tolkien’s innovation was not that Smaug could talk, but *how* he talked—with cunning, vanity, and a charismatic, evil personality.
An Archetype Perfected
Smaug stands on the shoulders of his literary ancestors. By synthesizing the terror of the Beowulf dragon with the greed of Fáfnir and adding his own narrative genius, Tolkien perfected the myth for a modern age.
Get Help with Your Literary Analysis